Best Mattress Protector: Reviews and Buyer’s Guide
If you’ve just bought a new mattress, the next best step is to protect it from damage with the best mattress protector. A new bed is a big purchase, so you want it to last for a long time. Protecting it from spills, sweat, dirt, germs, and pests like dust mites and bed bugs is the best way to prolong your investment. In this guide, we’ll talk about the different types of protectors on the market and what to consider before choosing one. In the end, we’ll discuss our favorite mattress protectors you can buy today.
30 Second Summary: Best Mattress Protectors
- Sleep Junkie’s Recommendation: Amerisleep’s Waterproof Mattress Protector & Cover. We like Amerisleep’s Waterproof Mattress Protector & Cover because it protects against spills, stains, dust mites, dirt, and bacteria. Plus, it’s breathable, easily washed, and backed by a 5-year warranty.
One of the main reasons people buy a mattress protector is to keep their mattress warranty intact. Most of the time, the warranty that comes with your new mattress is voided if the bed is stained; so even if you’re okay with sleeping on a mattress with a stain, you’ll be losing out on the benefits of having warranty coverage. Plus, a mattress protector can prolong the lifespan of your mattress up to a few years— saving you the hassle of having to replace your bed sooner.
Best Mattress Protectors
|Amerisleep Mattress Protectors||Waterproof, Dirt, & Dust-Mite Resistant||
|SafeRest||Waterproof, Dust-Mite, & Bacteria Resistant||
|Sureguard||Waterproof, Dust-Mite, Dander, Mold, Mildew, Bed-Bug Resistant||
|Utopia Bedding||Waterproof, Dust-Mite, & Bed-Bug Resistant||
|Avocado Green||Sweat & Skin Oils||
|Holy Lamb Organics||Sweat & Skin Oils||
|LUCID||Waterproof, Dust-Mite, & Allergen Resistant||
After weighing our options, we landed on Amerisleep’s Waterproof Mattress Protector & Cover as the best for your new bed. Instead of encasing your entire mattress, Amerisleep’s cover fits like a fitted sheet and can be easily removed when it comes time to throw it in the wash. It accommodates beds with a depth of 8 to 18 inches, encompassing a majority of mattresses. In addition to being waterproof, this cover is dirt and dust mite resistant and breathable enough to prevent bacteria from accumulating in your bed.
Amerisleep’s cover is Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certified, meaning it’s free from harsh chemicals. The materials in this cover include cotton, polyester jersey fabric, and polyurethane— a food-grade plastic that is more durable than latex. We should note, though polyurethane is not organic and is made using some chemicals, it’s still non-toxic and free from VOCs, PVC, and harmful chemicals. The use of polyurethane is what makes the mattress protector 100% waterproof, and unfortunately, there’s no all-natural way to waterproof a mattress protector without the use of either harsh chemicals or polyurethane.
When you buy a mattress protector with Amerisleep, it comes with a 5-year warranty against defects in the materials. It’s important to note, your warranty is voided if you don’t follow proper washing instructions. If your mattress protector does become stained, your warranty is not immediately voided; however, if you try to get the stain out yourself without seeking directions from the warranty department first, it would be voided. The price of a Queen Amerisleep mattress protector is $90.
2. SafeRest Mattress Protector
Next on our list is SafeRest’s Premium Hypoallergenic Waterproof Mattress Protector. As the name describes, SafeRest’s cover is both waterproof and hypoallergenic; plus, it’s Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certified. Additionally, SafeRest’s products are registered as a Class 1 medical device with the FDA, meaning they’re safe even for babies.
This mattress protector fits like a fitted sheet and protects against dust mites, allergens, fluids, and bacteria. The surface of this protector is cotton terry designed to be ultra-absorbent, while the underneath side is a polyurethane membrane, preventing any liquids from leaking onto the mattress. Because this cover slips on your bed like a fitted sheet, it can be easily removed for washing. Also, SafeRest offers a generous 10-year warranty with their protectors. However, be sure to follow all washing instructions carefully, because if your protector becomes damaged as a result of incorrect care, your warranty is voided.
The SafeRest mattress protector is compatible with mattresses between 6 and 18 inches in height and costs $69.95 for a Queen.
3. Sureguard Mattress Encasement
If you’re looking for a protector that will shield you from bed bugs, you need a mattress encasement. These differ from mattress protectors that fit like fitted sheets because they envelop your entire bed and zip shut. Though these are a bit hard to get on and off, making them tricky to wash, they’re the only kind of mattress cover that offers full coverage against bed bugs.
We liked the Sureguard Mattress Encasement because it is waterproof and hypoallergenic in addition to being bed bug-proof. It’s also dust mite, dander, dirt, mold, and mildew resistant. Just like the SafeRest cover we just talked about, the Sureguard Mattress Encasement has a cotton terry top and polyurethane inner membrane.
Two perks to shopping with Sureguard are that you receive a 30-day risk-free sleep trial and 10-year full-replacement warranty with your new mattress protector. They also offer a variety of sizes for their mattress encasements, so you can find one that’ll fit snug around your bed. After choosing the standard size of the cover, you’re then prompted to select the depth of your protector— the options are 6-8”, 9-12”, 13-16”, and 17-20”.
Sureguard only sells their products on Amazon, and the price for a Queen cover ranges from $49.97-$59.97 depending on the depth of the bed. However, Sureguard frequently runs promotions on their protectors, so you can sometimes find a better price by waiting to buy.
4. Utopia Bedding Premium Mattress Encasement
Another notable mattress encasement is made by Utopia Bedding and sold on Amazon for only $21.99. Utopia’s mattress protector zips up for ultimate protection, and keeps your bed free from bed bugs, dust mites, and safe from spills.
Utopia’s mattress encasement fits mattresses up to 15 inches thick, so it should be compatible with most beds. Plus, this mattress protector is machine washable and can be tumble dried for the most convenient cleaning. We like this mattress protector because it’s both thick and breathable; the knitted polyester fabric is durable and should be resistant to long-term wear and tear, but it’s quite airy so heat does not get trapped down within the protector.
5. Avocado Green Mattress Protector
Next on this list is an eco-friendly option for our green readers, the Avocado Green protector— which is also vegan! We want to mention first and foremost this mattress protector is not waterproof. Should you spill a drink, or have an accident on the mattress, this protector would not help. Remember, there’s no way to make a mattress protector truly waterproof without using chemicals or a polyurethane backing. An eco-friendly mattress protector will protect against sweat and oils from your skin damaging or staining the mattress, but that’s just about it. Unfortunately, these covers are not dust mite or bed bug resistant, either.
On the plus side, when it comes to buying eco-friendly, Avocado is the way to go. They use GOTS organic cotton, and the cover is free from polyurethane, TPUs, VOCs, formaldehyde, vinyl, adhesives, and chemical finishes. Just to note, GOTS certification ensures the materials Avocado uses— in this case, their cotton— meets the highest environmental and social standards for manufacturing.
When you buy with Avocado, you’re protected by a 1-year warranty. This cover costs $249 for a Queen and fits mattresses up to 17 inches tall.
6. Holy Lamb Organics Wool Moisture Barrier Mattress Protector
A more luxurious eco-friendly mattress protector is Holy Lamb Organic’s Wool Moisture Barrier. All in all, this protector prevents sweat and body oils from building up on your mattress over long-term use. Besides sweat though, this protector doesn’t shield your mattress from much. We’re fans of this cover because its 100% premium eco-friendly wool, so it’s warm, cozy, thick, and durable.
With a luxury cover, comes a more expensive price tag; a Queen Holy Lamb Organics Moisture Barrier will cost you $295. When reading customer reviews, we noticed they mentioned that this mattress protector does not fit like either a fitted sheet or an encasement; rather, it has the same dimensions as your mattress and sits on the surface of your bed underneath of your sheets. A few negative reviews of the cover were complaining that there is nothing to hold the moisture barrier in place, so it can be a hassle when it bunches below your bedding.
It seems the only downfall of using this protector is that it sometimes doesn’t stay in place, so if you’re looking for a wool mattress protector, you can’t go wrong by investing in the Holy Lamb Organics brand.
7. LUCID Premium Rayon from Bamboo Jersey Mattress Protector
The last mattress protector on our list is LUCID’s ultra-soft, waterproof, dust-mite proof, and hypoallergenic mattress protector, sold on Amazon for only $18.98. LUCID’s protector is 70% rayon from bamboo and 30% cotton, so it’s breathable, soft to the touch, and moisture-wicking, so it should help keep you comfy and cool all night long. They use their proprietary STRATOSMART barrier in this cover, which prevents liquids, dust mites, or allergens from getting through to the surface of your mattress while still being quite airy.
You can wash this cover with the rest of your bedding because it’s machine washable and tumble dryable, so it’s easy to keep clean. LUCID’s cover is compatible with mattesses up to 18 inches thick. When you buy this cover, it comes with a 15-year warranty, so LUCID’s cover is compatible with mattesses up to 18 inches thick.
Types of Mattress Protectors
Whether you’re looking to prevent normal wear and tear on a new bed and prefer to shop eco-friendly, or you’re protecting a new crib mattress from a little one’s bed-wetting, there’s a mattress protector to fit your needs. The main types of mattress protectors include waterproof protectors, bed-bug protectors, hypoallergenic covers, eco-friendly covers, and cooling covers. Sometimes, a mattress cover will have two significant benefits. For example, many bed bug mattress covers are also waterproof, so you get more bang for your buck if you buy a cover with more than one functionality.
Let’s talk about the key things to consider before choosing your best mattress protector.
Beyond looking at the standard size of your mattress—whether or not it’s a King, Queen, Full, or so on— you also have to measure the height of your bed. Most mattress protectors have a maximum depth, and you don’t want to buy a protector that’s too short. Before deciding on a protector, grab a tape measure and measure your mattress from top to bottom. Usually, it’ll clearly say on the protector’s packaging what size mattresses it’s compatible with; but if you don’t see it, read the fine print to make sure you’re making the right choice.
Just like your new bed comes with a warranty, so should your mattress protector. Many bedding companies sell their mattress protectors with warranties, so if you see a cover that does not come with a warranty, it’s probably safe to pass on. With a little more research, you can find a protector that’ll meet your needs and be backed with warranty coverage.
Apart from the technical considerations such as depth and warranty, it’s essential to ensure the mattress protector you choose is breathable and airy. If you buy a protector that doesn’t allow the mattress to breathe, dirt and dust mites can quickly accumulate, and your mattress can develop an unpleasant smell from the harboring of germs. A breathable mattress protector allows for air to flow in and out of the bed, which prevents against dust mites turning your new bed into their new home.
Did You Find Your New Mattress Protector?
Though there are numerous mattress protectors sold today, protecting your new bed from damage doesn’t have to be overwhelming. We hope this guide has helped you learn about what to consider before deciding on the best coverage for your mattress. Don’t forget, always read online reviews before buying any new bedding, as it helps give you insight into real customer experiences with the product and brand.