Amerisleep vs. Bear Mattress Reviews
Your mattress can mean the difference between a good night’s rest and endless tossing and turning. If you’re in the market for a new mattress, you might not know where to begin your search. Today, there are more options than ever before. To help you find your best mattress, we’ve put together this mattress comparison of Amerisleep and Bear — two top-rated online mattress brands — diving into their strengths and weaknesses as well as what type of sleeper might find them the most comfortable.
Amerisleep has been producing a unique line of memory foam mattresses and bedding since 2007. While they have several brick and mortar stores, they sell the bulk of their bed in a box mattresses online and offer free front door delivery through FedEx. Amerisleep also offers bedding, mattress covers, and foundations, including an adjustable bed for use with any of their models.
They use unique materials like Celliant® and Bio-Pur® to create a comfortable sleep experience. Amerisleep’s mattresses excel at contouring to the body and decreasing motion transfer. They’ve designed mattresses that accommodate all sleep positions— back, side, and stomach.
- AS1: The AS1’s firm surface works well for stomach and back sleepers as well as those who prefer a firm mattress. Though it may look simple with only two layers, the Bio-Pur® and Bio-Core® layers create a comfortable 10-inch mattress with light contouring and good breathability.
- AS2: The AS2 is Amerisleep’s medium-firm model. It’s slightly softer than the AS1 due to a transition layer between the Bio-Pur® and Bio-Core®, known as an Affinity layer. It provides zoned support at the hips and shoulders for more contouring and conformability.
- AS3: The AS3 balances support with conformability. Its medium feel makes it Amerisleep’s most popular model and best mattress for side sleepers. An Affinity transition layer adds zoned support to the Bio-Pur® layer, which is slightly thicker than the AS2’s.
- AS4: Four-inches of Bio-Pur® tops this medium-soft mattress. Like it does in the AS2 and AS3, the Affinity transition layer targets the body’s pressure points. However, it’s thinner in this model, so sleepers sink more deeply into the mattress.
- AS5: The AS5 is the ultimate in cushioned comfort with a fourth layer not found in any other Amerisleep model. This soft mattress has an Active Flex layer that improves the responsiveness of the thick comfort layer and allows sleepers to move without feeling stuck in the mattress.
Amerisleep’s Materials, Cover, and Construction
Amerisleep covers are made with a unique textile called Celliant®. Thirteen thermoreactive minerals weave throughout its surface, turning body heat into infrared energy. The infrared energy then penetrates muscle tissue and promotes blood flow. In addition to these special properties, Celliant® covers are removable and machine washable.
On the inside, Amerisleep mattresses have high-quality materials designed for comfort and cooling. The simplest but firmest model —the AS1— has a two-inch comfort layer made of an advanced open-cell foam called Bio-Pur®. It offers cushioning with light contouring on top of a dense, eight-inch Bio-Core® support layer. Foams with advanced open-cell structures like Bio-Pur® have more space for air to flow yet don’t compromise support or structure. Bio-Core® acts as the support for all of Amerisleep’s mattresses.
The medium-firm AS2’s two-inch Bio-Pur® comfort layer cushions the body as it sinks into a three-inch Affinity layer with HIVE® technology (Harnessing Intelligent Ventilation & Energy). This Affinity layer’s hexagonal cutouts are arranged in five zones. The cutouts are closely arranged for more support at the head, back, and feet. At the shoulders and hips, they’re spaced farther apart to relieve pressure. HIVE® technology also improves breathability as it allows air to flow through and around the cutouts.
The AS3, Amerisleep’s medium-feel model, tops its sales charts because of its ability to appeal to almost all sleep styles. Its thick, three-inch Bio-Pur® comfort layer offers more cushioning than the AS2. However, it still maintains targeted support with an Affinity layer that relieves pressure at the hips and shoulders. It has the same Bio-Core® support layer as other Amerisleep models.
Taking softness up another level, Amerisleep’s medium-soft mattress —the AS4— cradles the body with a four-inch-thick Bio-Pur® comfort layer. A one-inch Affinity layer prevents the sleeper from sinking too far and offers extra support where it’s needed. The high-density Bio-Core® support layer provides shape and durability.
The AS5 is Amerisleep’s softest and only four-layer mattress. It has a four-inch Bio-Pur® layer on top of a two-inch Active Flex layer. Active Flex lets sleepers sink into the mattress without getting stuck in the pressure-relieving foam. The AS5 also has the Affinity layer to target sensitive pressure points. Of course, it too has the Bio-Core® support layer.
Amerisleep’s Cooling Technologies and Temperature Regulation
Amerisleep keeps sleepers cool using a combination of technologies and techniques. Their Celliant® covers convert body heat into energy, which goes back into the sleeper’s body. Bio-Pur’s® advanced open-cell structure lets air pass through the foam, so it doesn’t stay trapped next to the sleeper. Finally, HIVE® technology keeps air circulating through the transition layer. Together, these technologies create mattresses with above-average temperature regulation.
Amerisleep Mattresses’ Support, Conformability, and Motion Isolation
Amerisleep’s high-quality memory foam mattresses get top marks for their motion isolation and conformability. Their five models work for many types of sleepers because they provide a range of conformability and support options.
The AS1 and AS2, with their thinner top layers, support sleepers with light cushioning. Their firm and medium-firm support work well for back and stomach sleepers. The softest mattresses —the AS4 and AS5— offer deep cushioning and cradling of painful pressure points. Side and combo sleepers are more likely to find comfort deep with these two mattresses.
The AS3 offers a middle ground between support and conformability. Sleepers with a variety of sleep styles have the potential to find comfort on the AS3. Couples may also want to consider it because it can accommodate sleepers with different sleep styles.
All Amerisleep models have excellent motion isolation. Couples can focus on support and conformability with the assurance that motion from a restless partner won’t transfer across the mattress’s surface.
Foam mattresses tend to lack the edge support of hybrids and innerspring models. Amerisleep’s models have average edge support for this type of mattress.
How Durable are Amerisleep Mattresses?
Amerisleep’s high-quality, high-density foams give their mattresses excellent durability for a foam mattress. Bio-Core®’s solid design and structure, in particular, boost the durability and longevity of Amerisleep mattresses. Amerisleep’s 20-year warranty reflects that quality. The warranty includes replacement of the mattress for indentations over three-quarters of an inch. That’s in line with the best foam mattress warranties on the market.
A typical foam mattress may last six to eight years. As long as an Amerisleep mattress is supported on an adequate mattress foundation and maintained properly, you’re looking at a longer than average life expectancy of well over eight years.
Amerisleep’s Trial Period, Warranty, and Return Policies
Amerisleep mattresses come with a 100-night sleep trial. The mattress can be returned at any time in that period. However, they recommend you try the mattress for at least 30 days before returning it. If a return is requested, Amerisleep pays for and sends someone to pick up and return your old mattress. When possible, they donate returned mattresses to those in need. If donating isn’t an option in your area, they will recycle the mattress. There are no restocking fees.
Amerisleep mattresses have a 20-year, prorated warranty that is broken into two parts. In the first ten years, the mattress will be replaced or repaired if there are workmanship or structural defects. In the second ten years, they will repair or replace the mattress for 50 percent of the original purchase price.
There are limitations to the warranty throughout the 20-year period. The mattress must be kept on an appropriate foundation or base, as defined in the warranty. Tears, stains, and burns are not considered defects. However, the warranty does apply to indentations of more than three-quarters of an inch that are not due to an improper foundation. Finally, the warranty only applies to the original owner with proof of purchase.
Amerisleep’s Social Responsibility
Whenever possible, Amerisleep works with local charities and organizations to arrange the donation of returned mattresses. Their shipping, packaging, and manufacturing processes are also designed to be eco-friendly and reduce their overall carbon footprint.
Who Are Amerisleep Mattresses For?
Amerisleep’s five models present a wide range of comfort options. That allows sleepers to base their choices on their personal preferences and needs for conformability and support.
The AS1 and AS2 prevent sinkage, making them a popular choice for stomach and back sleepers. The AS2 also works well for heavyweight sleepers who prefer a firmer surface. For the side and combo sleeper who like to sink into the mattress, the AS4 and AS5 with their extra conformability and lighter support are excellent options. The AS3 provides the best of both worlds— it has good support and incredible conformability that make it an excellent choice for couples and those who prefer a medium-feel mattress.
Bear is a family-owned and operated business that entered the mattress world in 2015. They market their three mattresses to athletes and those with an active lifestyle. The main selling point is the Celliant® technology in their covers, which they have in common with Amerisleep. All three models have various types of cooling technologies like graphite memory foam, copper foam, and gel memory foam.
Bear only sells their mattresses online and delivers them bed-in-a-box style. They also sell their own line of bedding products, including mattress covers, sheets, pillows, foundations, and adjustable bed frames.
- Bear Mattress: This original model is the most basic of Bear’s mattresses. It has a graphite-gel memory foam comfort layer that cushions, conforms, and supports the body. It rests on top of a poly-foam transition layer and a high-density poly-foam support core. This medium-firm mattress appeals to back and stomach sleepers more than side sleepers due to its firmer feel.
- Bear Hybrid: The Hybrid’s combination of hypersoft cooling-gel foam, comfort foam, transition foam, and pocketed coil design give it a medium-firm feel that’s slightly softer than the Bear Mattress. To prevent the sleeper from rolling off, it has targeted edge support.
- Bear Pro: Bear’s newest model has copper-infused foam with anti-microbial properties. A layer of gel memory foam moves heat away from the sleeper’s body while a responsive foam prevents sleepers from feeling stuck in its contoured layers. Finally, a high-density support core gives the mattress shape and longevity.
Bear’s Materials, Cover, and Construction
Like Amerisleep, Bear’s covers utilize Celliant® for its ability to transform body heat into infrared energy. It’s used on all three Bear models. All Bear mattresses are also CertiPUR-US® certified, which means their foams are free of substances like formaldehyde, mercury, and chemical flame retardants.
The medium-firm Bear Mattress’s three layers contour and cushion at the body’s pressure points to keep the spine aligned. The two-inch graphite-gel memory foam comfort layer conforms to the curves of the body. The graphite and gel move heat away from the sleeper. The second layer consists of a poly-foam that cushions the body but has a higher density for added support. These two layers lie on top of a 6-inch high-density poly-foam base.
The Bear Hybrid mattress’s Celliant® cover is quilted to a hypersoft cooling-gel foam, adding some cushioning over the comfort layer and pulling heat away from the sleeper. Next is a layer of premium comfort form that conforms to the body, much like memory foam. The size of the cells in this foam helps air move through this layer, so it doesn’t overheat the sleeper.
The comfort foam is followed by a thin layer of transition foam. This layer adds responsiveness to prevent sleepers from feeling stuck. The support core consists of six-inch pocketed coils with Bear’s Quantum Edge Coil System, which adds support at the edges, so there’s less sinkage and breakdown. Finally, there’s a one-inch high-density poly-foam base. This 14-inch mattress is rated medium-firm, but it’s slightly softer than the Bear Mattress. The Hybrid is both CertiPUR-US® and Greenguard Gold certified, which means its contents have also passed tests for harmful VOCs.
The Bear Pro’s medium-firm support system starts with a comfort layer that consists of copper-infused memory foam. Copper serves dual purposes in this mattress. First, it acts as a conductor that pulls heat away from the body. Second, copper is naturally anti-microbial, so it acts as a protective, hygienic layer. A gel memory foam layer lies underneath to conform further and cradle the body. It’s followed by a responsive transition poly-foam. This layer brings cushioning but responds more readily to the sleeper’s movement. Finally, a high-density poly-foam support core provides shape and durability.
Bear’s Cooling Technologies and Temperature Regulation
Bear uses several technologies to regulate sleeper temperature. All Bear mattresses have a Celliant® cover that utilizes body heat to create infrared energy. The Bear Mattress has a graphite gel memory foam to absorb heat and move it away from the sleeper. The Hybrid’s open-cell foams create space for air to move through. Once the heat reaches the pocketed coils, it can move and circulate even farther so that it doesn’t overheat the sleeper. Finally, the Bear Pro has copper-infused memory foam and a layer of gel memory foam. Both absorb and circulate heat away from the sleeper.
Of the three Bear models, their hybrid mattress generally sleeps the coolest because of the extra airflow around the coils.
Bear Mattresses’ Support, Conformability, and Motion Isolation
Both the Bear Mattress and the Pro isolate motion well. The Hybrid’s pocketed coils aren’t interconnected, so they target pressure relief and reduce motion transfer. However, couples will feel more motion from a restless sleeper on the Hybrid than they would on a memory foam or all-foam mattress. Both the Bear Mattress and the Pro lack the edge support of the Hybrid, which means you’re more likely to sink at the edge or feel like you’re falling out of bed.
All three Bear models rate as medium-firm on the firmness scale. However, they have marginally different levels of conformability. The Hybrid and Pro both offer slightly more sinkage than the Bear Mattress. The softer Pro offers more contouring than the other two models.
Both the Bear Mattress and the Pro absorb motion extremely well. While the Hybrid’s foam layers absorb motion, the responsiveness of the pocketed coils will cause more motion transference than with the Bear Mattress, Pro, or similar memory foam mattresses.
How Durable are Bear Mattresses?
The quality and density of the Bear’s materials and foams suggest their mattresses should last the industry average of six to eight years. Their warranties reflect that durability. The Bear Mattress and Pro each have a ten-year warranty while the Hybrid has a twenty-year warranty.
Bear’s Trial Period, Warranty, and Return Policies
All Bear mattresses come with a 100-night sleep trial with a 30-day break-in period. If within that window you decide you do not like the mattress, Bear will arrange for the mattress to be picked up. When possible, they have mattresses picked-up by local charities. A return is only allowed on the first mattress purchase, so one return per customer, household, and/or delivery address.
The Bear Mattress and the Pro have a ten-year warranty that covers defects in the foam or indentations over one inch that aren’t due to an improper foundation. The warranty does not include normal changes in the softness of the mattress, burns, or tears due to improper handling or use. If a warranty claim is substantiated, Bear will take care of the cost of replacement or repair, but the purchaser must pay for shipping and handling costs.
The Hybrid comes with a 20-year warranty that covers defects and indentations over 1.5 inches. It, too, must be kept on a proper foundation for the warranty to be valid. For the first ten years of the warranty, Bear will replace or repair a defective mattress at their cost except for the cost of shipping and handling. In year 11, if the mattress is deemed defective, Bear will either repair the mattress or replace it at 50 percent of the cost of the original purchase price. If the mattress is replaced during years 12 through 20, the rate charged to the purchaser increases by 5 percent each year. For example, in year 12, they would pay 55 percent of the original cost; in year 13, they would pay 60 percent of the original price.
All warranties only apply to the original purchaser with proof of purchase.
Bear’s Social Responsibility
Bear partners with Good Sports to donate athletic equipment and funds to children’s sports programs. Their foams are CertiPUR-US® certified, which means they’re free of chemical fire retardants, mercury, lead, and ozone depleters. The Hybrid is both CertiPUR-US® certified and Greenguard Gold certified, meaning it’s also free of VOCs.
Who Are Bear Mattresses For?
Bear designs their mattresses for athletes and those with an active lifestyle. The firmer Bear Mattress works better for back and stomach sleepers as well as couples due to its ability to absorb motion. The softer Hybrid and Pro with their deeper conformability and pressure relief fit the needs of back and side sleepers. However, these models are also medium-firm, so some side sleepers and even a few back sleepers may find them too firm.
Amerisleep vs. Bear: The Bottom Line
- Both Amerisleep and Bear use Celliant® in their mattress covers for added sleeper health and better temperature control.
- All of Amerisleep’s mattresses come with a prorated 20-year warranty while only the Bear Hybrid’s warranty is that long.
- Amerisleep offers mattresses in five firmness levels, whereas all of Bear’s models tend to fall within the medium-firm category.
- Both brand’s mattresses incorporate the efficient, impressive cooling technologies.
Choosing your mattress is a highly personal decision. What works for you may not work for your best friend or neighbor. Ask yourself what sleep position you prefer, how responsive you like your mattress to be, and whether you sleep hot or cold. The answer to these questions will guide you to the mattress that helps you get a full seven to nine hours of sleep.