Online shopping has made everyday life easier for a variety of reasons. In today’s age, you can buy practically everything you need from the comfort of your couch. Having this convenience helps you save time running errands when it comes to buying groceries or clothing online. However, when it comes to mattresses, having the ability to buy online changes the way you shop. Before, shopping for a new bed included making a visit to every mattress retailer in your zip code and avoiding pushy store employees once out and about on the sales floor. Now, you can learn about a variety of beds at your own speed, read bed in a box mattress reviews, and thoughtfully weigh the pros and cons of all of your options before coming to a decision.
In this guide, we’ll be discussing our four favorite bed in a box brands and their best mattress models to assist in your search for the most comfortable mattress.
The Amerisleep AS3 is our Editors’ Choice as the best bed in a box mattress because it’s versatile enough to be comfortable for a variety of sleepers and fosters healthy sleep positions.
- How to Buy Online
- Sleep Trials
- Four Best Online Mattress Brands
- Have You Found the Right Bed in a Box for You?
How to Buy Online
Buying a mattress without every trying it first can seem like a weird thing to do. How could you possibly feel confident you’ve made the right choice without having the chance to at least feel it? Before clicking purchase, there are a few things you can take into account when choosing your next mattress that’ll help you pick the right bed.
For starters, consider how you sleep. Do you spend a majority of the night laying on your back, or would you consider yourself to be a side sleeper? How you sleep plays a role when choosing how firm your mattress should be. Usually, stomach and back sleepers do well on firmer mattresses because they’re supportive enough to foster a healthy spine and relieve pressure points. Whereas side sleepers are most comfortable on a medium or soft mattress because they’re soft enough to allow the hips and shoulders to compress in the bed, easing tension.
Next, think about how you feel in the mornings. When you roll out of bed do you feel refreshed and ready for the day? Oppositely, are you usually struggling to get out of bed with aches and pains? If you find yourself plagued with lower back and neck pains more often than not, it’s a good sign the bed you’re currently sleeping on isn’t a good fit for you. Meaning, if you’re used to sleeping a firm bed, it may be time to switch to something softer, and vise versa.
Then, take your preference for firmness into consideration. Do you prefer a more “cradling” feeling from your mattress? If so, a softer memory foam bed may be a comfortable match. Alternatively, do you like a firmer, “lifting” feeling from your bed? If that’s the case, you may be better suited on a firmer latex bed. Regardless of your preference, there are suitable options out there to explore.
Even if you feel as if you’re making the most educated decision, it can still be daunting to make a large investment in a mattress without being absolutely sure it’s suitable for you. To make online buying possible, many online mattress brands offer risk-free sleep trials. Sleep trials allow you to test the bed in your own home for a certain number of nights and decide if it’s the best fit for you. During this time, you have the option to return your mattress for a full refund if you decide against keeping it. Some brands will also give you the option to exchange your mattress for a different one of their models if you think one of their other beds would be a more comfortable fit.
Before purchasing a mattress online, double check to see if the brand offers a sleep trial and be sure to read the return policy guidelines. Most brands offer free returns as a part of their risk-free sleep trial, but some brands charge hidden transportation or restocking fees. If you’re unclear about anything in the return policy, ask for clarification so you have a thorough understanding of the agreement you’re getting into before you buy.
In the next section, we’ll talk about our four favorite online mattress brands of 2019 and who we recommend their beds for.
Four Best Online Bed in a Box Mattress Brands
A decade ago, there were only a few online mattress brands on the market, including BedInABox® and Amerisleep. As the years went on, brands like Casper and Tuft and Needle were founded and quickly became popular. Now, there are a variety of brands on the market to learn about; however, the Editors’ of Sleep Junkie recommend shopping with Amerisleep, Leesa, Nolah, and Casper.
Our Editors’ choice for the best mattress in a box is Amerisleep’s AS3. Amerisleep was one of the first online mattress brands and has been around long enough to establish a reliable, positive reputation for itself. Being in business since 2007, this brand has had time to learn the ins and outs of the online mattress industry and delivers quality beds. Customer reviews of the brand mention their excellent customer service, too. When you shop with Amerisleep, your mattress comes with a risk-free 100-night sleep trial and a lengthy 20-year warranty. For these reasons, we chose Amerisleep as our most recommended brand to shop with.
Amerisleep sells four mattresses, each of which ranges in firmness and are designed with specific sleepers in mind. Their AS1 and AS2 are firm and medium-firm, respectively, and built for back and stomach sleepers. The AS3 is a medium model and is versatile enough to be a fit for a variety of sleepers. Amerisleep recommends this bed for back, side, and combination sleepers alike because it is adaptable to contour to your body regardless of your sleeping position. Lastly, Amerisleep sells its AS4 and AS5, which completes its soft mattress collection. We recommend the AS3 mattress because it’s built for a large variety of sleepers, and it’s listed on their website as their most popular model.
Let’s look at the layers of this bed and the materials Amerisleep uses.
- Every Amerisleep bed has a Celliant® cover. Celliant® fabric has been determined by the FDA to promote more restful sleep by regulating your body temperature. It does this by recycling the body heat you naturally emit while you sleep into infrared light. Your body absorbs infrared light, which in turn increases local blood flow. Increased local blood flow should prevent you from waking up overheated on this mattress.
- The first layer of the AS3 is Amerisleep’s Bio-Pur® foam. This plant-based foam is designed to be more breathable than traditional memory foam, working in conjunction with the Celliant® cover above to keep you cool. When you lay down on this layer, the Bio-Pur® foam should contour to your body’s curves and offer immediate comfort. As you compress into this layer, it should release pressure points and tension.
- Next, is a layer of HIVE® technology. Amerisleep uses this technology to provide exceptional targeted support to its customers. They make this technology by strategically placing hexagon-shaped cutouts into five comfort zones throughout this layer. These comfort zones are firmer where your body needs more support, so in your head, shoulders, back, hips, and feet, and softer where your body needs additional comfort.
- The bottom layer of the AS3 is high-density Bio-Core® foam. Amerisleep designs this foam to be long-lasting and durable to prevent against premature deterioration, impressions, and sagging. They back their beds with an impressive 20-year warranty, as we mentioned earlier, so your bed is protected for the next two decades.
Leesa was founded in 2015 and sells two different mattresses, their flagship Leesa bed, and the Leesa hybrid. While well-known for its quality beds, this brand also stands out amongst the crowd when it comes to their social initiatives. Their One-Ten program ensures one mattress is donated for every 10 Leesa sells. In April every year, they plant 10 trees for every mattress they sell in honor of Earth Day. Leesa goes out of their way to help both our Earth and our communities, earning them their spot on this list.
When shopping with Leesa, you receive a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty with your bed. If you’re thinking of buying a Leesa, we recommend choosing their all-foam flagship model.
Below, we’ll talk about how Leesa designs the layers of this bed.
- The cover of the Leesa mattress is a polyester blend— it feels soft and cozy to the touch but is also breathable enough to allow for air to pass through.
- The first layer of the Leesa mattress is Leesa’s proprietary LSA 200 foam. Instead of using memory foam or latex foam alone, Leesa designs this poly-foam to feel like a mix of the two materials. When you lay on this layer, it should have a more responsive and bouncier feel than memory foam, but will still contour to your body’s curves. This material is also designed to be breathable, so it should help keep you cool at night.
- Next, is a layer of memory foam, in place to offer extra contouring. A common concern with memory foam is its tendency to trap body heat. By placing the layer of memory foam below the layer of poly-foam, Leesa reduces the chance of this bed sleeping hot.
- The last layer of the Leesa is a dense poly-foam base. This high-density foam gives the Leesa its shape as well as structural and edge support.
Nolah is a relatively new brand to the online mattress industry, and their biggest selling point is their mission to create “tomorrow’s mattress.” Instead of using traditional mattress materials such as memory foam or latex foam, Nolah mattress engineers their own Nolah AirFoam™ to use in their beds. Nolah sells two mattresses, both of twice are designed to be comfortable for the majority of sleepers. In addition to focusing on crafting the most comfortable mattress, Nolah sleep puts a big emphasis on their wildlife initiatives. When you buy a mattress with Nolah, they adopt an endangered American animal through their wildlife conservation partner, Defenders of Wildlife.
When you buy a Nolah bed, it comes with a 120-night sleep trial and a 15-year warranty. We recommend choosing their Original 10” Nolah bed and below we’ll break down the layers of this model.
- The cover of the Nolah is polyester and viscose, which should feel both soft and cooling to the touch.
- The first layer of their mattress is their proprietary Nolah AirFoam™, designed to be contouring like memory foam, but more breathable. When you lay on this bed, you should sink into this layer, making it a great choice for side sleepers who need extra pressure relief for their hips and shoulders.
- Next, is a layer of more responsive, latex-like foam. When you sink through the top layer, this layer should suspend you in the mattress and prevent you from sinking uncomfortably far. This layer acts primarily as a transition between the soft Nolah AirFoam™ above and the dense core foam below.
- The final layer of this mattress is high-density poly-foam in place to give this bed shape and structure.
Casper Sleep is one of the most well-known online mattress brands on the market today. Founded in 2014, this brand has expanded rapidly; starting with only one mattress, Casper now sells a variety of sleep accessories including pillows, night lights, sheets, duvets, nightstands, and even dog beds.
Over the years, Casper has started making and selling more mattresses in addition to their flagship Casper bed, including the Essential and the Wave. In 2019, they released hybrid versions of their Casper and Wave, giving customers more of a variety. When shopping with Casper, we recommend sticking to their popular flagship model, and every Casper bed comes with a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty.
- The cover of the Casper is a polyester blend, soft and stretchy. Because this cover is zippable, it can easily be removed for cleaning.
- The first layer of this mattress is Casper’s latex-like poly-foam. Designed to be more responsive than memory foam, this layer has a bit of bounce. This material is also quite breathable, so it shouldn’t trap heat.
- Next, is a layer of memory foam in place to contour to your body’s curves and relieve pressure points.
- Below is a zoned support layer of poly-foam. At the head and feet of the bed, this layer feels softer, allowing your body to sink in; however, this layer feels firmer in the center to offer enhanced lumbar support.
- The base of the mattress is high-density poly-foam designed to hold its shape for years to last, preventing against early sagging.
Have You Found the Right Bed in a Box for You?
We hope this guide has helped you find the most comfortable bed in a box for your sleep needs. Remember, consider your sleep style, frequent aches and pains, and your preference for firmness and materials when choosing your next bed. Before clicking purchase, have a thorough understanding of the bed you’re buying and the perks it comes with including sleep trial and warranty. If you take your time and do research before making a purchase, you should feel confident buying the best mattress for your sleep needs online.