Amerisleep vs. Nolah Mattress Reviews
The mattress market grows ever more competitive every year. In one way, that’s great because you have a good field of options. In another, it makes it that much more daunting to wade through all your choices. Amerisleep and Nolah each have a different take and approach to nightly comfort. Our mattress comparison lets you evaluate what each brand has to offer. You may even find one of their models makes the best mattress for you.
Amerisleep is not a newcomer to the mattress business. They’ve been producing a unique line of bed in a box mattresses and bedding since 2007.
Their five models range in support and firmness to create options for all sleep positions— stomach, back, and side. Amerisleep uses unique materials like Celliant® and Bio-Pur® to counteract the heat build-up associated with traditional memory foam. What’s more, their mattresses offer excellent conformability and motion isolation. With Amerisleep, the key is finding a model with the right firmness and cushioning based on your sleep preferences.
- AS1: If you’re a stomach or back sleeper and you prefer a firmer mattress, the AS1 might be for you. Its two layers of Bio-Pur® and Bio-Core® stand ten inches high, making it Amerisleep’s lowest profile model.
- AS2: The AS2 is similar to the AS1, except that it has a third layer, making it slightly softer than the AS1 (a true medium-firm feel). The extra layer, known as the Affinity layer, offers zoned support at the shoulders and hips for increased conformability.
- AS3: If you need a balance of support and conformability, Amerisleep’s most popular model— the AS3— has a medium feel that appeals to most sleep positions. A comfort layer that’s slightly thicker than the AS2 adds cushioning, while there’s still zoned support for the hips and shoulders— making it one of the best mattresses for side sleepers.
- AS4: A four-inch layer of Bio-Pur® tops this medium-soft mattress. The Affinity transition layer still targets pressure points like in the AS3, but it’s thinner in this model, so sleepers sink more deeply into the mattress layers.
- AS5: The AS5 is the ultimate in cushioned comfort with a fourth layer not found in any other Amerisleep model. This Active Flex layer improves the responsiveness of the deep layers of conforming foam so that sleepers can move without feeling stuck in the mattress.
While they have several brick and mortar stores, they sell the bulk of their mattresses online and include front door delivery. Amerisleep also overs bedding, mattress covers, and foundations, including an adjustable bed for use with any of their mattresses.
Amerisleep’s Materials, Cover, and Construction
Amerisleep uses a unique textile technology in their mattress covers called Celliant® that has 13 thermoreactive minerals woven into it. The FDA* determined that Celliant® safely converts body heat into infrared energy. The infrared energy then penetrates muscle tissue and temporarily increases local blood flow. In addition to these special properties, Celliant® covers are removable and machine washable.
Let’s take a closer look at Amerisleep’s memory foam mattresses. The simplest but firmest model— the AS1— has two layers. A two-inch comfort layer made of an advanced open-cell memory foam called Bio-Pur® offers slight cushioning and light contouring. Foams with open cells like Bio-Pur® have more space for air to flow yet don’t compromise support or structure. A dense eight-inch Bio-Core® support layer brings shape and durability to this mattress and the other four Amerisleep models.
The medium-firm AS2 starts with a two-inch Bio-Pur® comfort layer. A three-inch Affinity layer with HIVE® technology (Harnessing Intelligent Ventilation & Energy) separates the comfort layer from the support core. This special layer has hexagonal cutouts arranged in five zones. The cutouts are closely arranged for more support at the head, back, and feet. At the shoulders and hips, they’re spaced farther apart to relieve pressure. HIVE® technology also improves breathability as it allows air to flow through and around the cutouts.
The AS3, Amerisleep’s medium-feel model, tops their sales charts because of its ability to appeal to almost all sleep styles. Its thick, three-inch Bio-Pur® comfort layer offers more cushioning than the AS2. However, it still maintains targeted support with an Affinity layer that relieves pressure at the hips and shoulders. It has the same Bio-Core® support layer as other Amerisleep models.
Taking softness up another level, Amerisleep’s medium-soft mattress —the AS4— cradles the body with a four-inch-thick Bio-Pur® comfort layer. A one-inch Affinity layer prevents the sleeper from sinking too far and offers extra support where it’s needed. Supporting it all is the standard Bio-Core® support layer.
The AS5 is Amerisleep’s softest and only four-layer mattress. It has a four-inch Bio-Pur® layer on top of a two-inch Active Flex layer that lets sleepers sink into the mattress without getting stuck in the conformability of the foam. Active Flex only appears in the AS5 and actively improves the responsiveness of the mattress, making it a suitable soft mattress for heavy sleepers. It also has the Affinity layer to target sensitive pressure points.
Amerisleep’s Cooling Technologies and Temperature Regulation
Amerisleep keeps sleepers cool using a combination of technologies and techniques. Celliant® uses body heat to the sleeper’s advantage, while Bio-Pur®’s advanced open-cell structure lets more air pass through the foam’s individual cells. Finally, HIVE® technology keeps that air moving through the transition layer so that it doesn’t stay trapped near the sleeper. The results are cooling memory foam mattresses with above-average temperature regulation.
Amerisleep Mattresses’ Support, Conformability, and Motion Isolation
Amerisleep mattresses stand out for their motion isolation and ability to conform to the curves of the body. Amerisleep’s five models provide a range of support and conformability options. That allows them to work for an equally wide range of sleepers.
The softest mattresses— the AS4 and AS5— cushion and cradle painful pressure points. They typically appeal to side and combo sleepers. The AS1 and AS2 have thinner top layers, so there’s less depth to the cushioning, but they still hug and cradle the sleeper. However, their firmer support is better suited to back and stomach sleepers.
The AS3 straddles the line between conformability and support. There are sleepers of all sleep styles who can find comfort in its layers. The AS3 is a great choice for couples who may have differing sleep styles and body weights.
All Amerisleep models have excellent motion isolation. Couples can focus on support and conformability with the assurance that motion from a restless partner won’t transfer across the surface of the mattress.
Foam mattresses tend to lack the edge support of hybrids and innerspring models. Amerisleep’s models have average edge support for this type of mattress.
How Durable are Amerisleep Mattresses?
The high-quality, high-density foams used in Amerisleep mattresses gives them excellent durability for a memory foam mattress. Bio-Core®, in particular, adds incredible durability to these models. Their 20-year warranty reflects that quality. The warranty includes replacement of the mattress for indentations over three-quarters of an inch. That’s on par with the best mattress warranties (the standard warranty length for mattresses is ten years).
A typical memory foam mattress may last six to eight years. As long as an Amerisleep mattress is supported on the proper foundation and adequately maintained, you’re looking at a longer than average life expectancy of well over eight years.
Amerisleep’s Trial Period, Warranty, and Return Policies
Amerisleep mattresses come with a 100-night sleep trial. The mattress can be returned at any time in that period; however, they recommend you try the mattress for at least 30 days before returning it. If a return is requested, Amerisleep will take care of picking up and returning the mattress. When possible, they try to donate returned mattresses; but if donating isn’t an option in your area, they will recycle the mattress. There are no restocking fees.
Amerisleep mattresses have a 20-year, prorated warranty that is broken into two parts. In the first ten years, the mattress will be replaced or repaired if there are workmanship or structural defects. In the second ten years, they will repair or replace the mattress for 50 percent of the original purchase price.
There are limitations to the warranty throughout the 20-year period. The mattress must be kept on an appropriate foundation or base as defined in the warranty. Tears, stains, and burns are not considered defects. However, the warranty does apply to indentations of more than three-quarters of an inch that are not due to an improper foundation. Finally, the warranty only applies to the original owner along with proof of purchase.
Amerisleep’s Social Responsibility
Whenever possible, Amerisleep works with local charities and organizations to arrange the donation of returned mattresses. Their shipping, packaging, and manufacturing processes are also designed to be eco-friendly and reduce their overall carbon footprint.
Who Are Amerisleep Mattresses For?
Amerisleep’s five models combine for a wide range of comfort options. It’s a matter of individual sleepers finding a support and conformability level that works for their personal preferences.
The AS1 and AS2 are just the right firmness for stomach and back sleepers. The AS2 works well for heavyweight sleepers who prefer a firmer surface. The AS4 and AS5 with their extra conformability and lighter support appeal to side and combination sleepers. The AS3 is the mid-point between support and comfortability for couples and those who prefer a medium feel mattress. With Amerisleep, it’s a matter of finding the right fit for each person or couple.
The creators of Nolah mattresses wanted an alternative to traditional memory foam and the growing latex foam trend. They created their own, temperature neutral proprietary foam known as Nolah AirFoam™ that conforms to the body’s pressure points like memory foam does.
They offer their own line of bases, including an adjustable base and a massage base with built-in USB ports. Nolah’s products also extend into pillows and cotton or bamboo mattress protectors. As an online retailer, Nolah delivers their mattresses to your front door bed-in-a-box style.
- Nolah Original 10: This three-layer, medium-feel mattress has Nolah’s proprietary AirFoam™ top layer. It conforms to the body, making it comfortable for side and back sleepers. However, it may be too soft for stomach sleepers.
- Nolah Signature 12: A flippable mattress like the Signature 12 gives sleepers more options than usual. Its plush, medium side accommodates side sleepers while the firm side caters to stomach sleepers and those who need firmer support.
Nolah’s Materials, Cover, and Construction
The Original has a polyester/viscose mattress cover that’s smooth and breathable. This stretchy material moves with the mattress, so the sleeper can take full advantage of the conformability without any constriction from the cover. The Signature comes with a soft, organic cotton mattress cover that’s equally stretchy and flexible.
The Nolah Original 10 gets its name from the three layers that combine to make its 10-inch height. The comfort layer consists of two inches of Nolah AirFoam™. AirFoam™ has similar qualities to memory foam, such as conformability and relief at pressure points. However, it tends to bounce back into its original shape faster. A 1.5-inch transition poly-foam provides cushioning before the sleeper feels the seven-inch high-density poly-foam support core.
The Nolah Signature 12 brings extra options to the bedroom with a flippable design. Its 12-inch profile comes from four layers. The soft side of the Signature has 2.5-inches of Nolah AirFoam™ over a 1.5-inch poly-foam transition layer. The thicker comfort layer allows the sleeper to sink more deeply than they would on the Nolah Original.
A seven-inch high-density poly-foam support core keeps the spine aligned for both the soft and firm sides. If you flip the mattress, you’ll find a thin one-inch AirFoam™ comfort layer. It’s a good mattress for stomach sleepers and those who prefer a firmer bed. You’ll get some conformability, but the support prevents too much sinkage.
All of Nolah’s foams are CertiPUR-US® certified. That means they’ve passed independent regulations and testing for durability and are free of substances like ozone depleters, chemical flame retardants, and formaldehyde.
Nolah’s Cooling Technologies and Temperature Regulation
Nolah AirFoam™ is designed to provide the conformability of memory foam with improved air circulation. AirFoam™ performs about on par with foams of similar densities, which means there’s more heat than you would find in an innerspring or hybrid mattress but with slightly better temperature regulation than traditional memory foam.
Nolah Mattresses’ Support, Conformity, and Motion Isolation
AirFoam™ conforms well to the curves of the body, much like memory foam, but with a gentler hug of the body. The AirFoam™ provides good pressure relief at the hips and shoulders for side sleepers and back sleepers who like to sink into the mattress. Neither the Original nor the soft side of the Signature have the support for stomach sleepers. Their hips are likely to sink, which can throw the spine out of alignment.
However, the firm side of the Signature conforms with firm support for stomach sleepers and those who prefer a firm mattress.
Nolah’s models prevent motion transfer from spreading across the surface of the mattress. Both of these models are a good option for couples, especially if one partner is a restless sleeper.
Finally, there’s edge support. Like Amerisleep, Nolah’s mattresses perform about average for foam beds, since the edge sinks more than in a hybrid or innerspring model.
How Durable are Nolah Mattresses?
All-foam mattresses typically last six to eight years. The Original and Signature should last at least that long and possibly beyond. The Signature’s limited lifetime warranty and foam densities suggest that the manufacturer expects it to last well past the typical mattress life span.
Nolah’s Trial Period, Warranty, and Return Policies
Nolah mattresses come with a 120-night trial. There’s a 30 day required break-in period, but after that, you can return the mattress for a full refund within the trial window. Nolah will pay for, arrange, and take care of the mattress pick up.
The Original comes with a 15-year limited warranty. The warranty only applies to the original owner of the mattress. It covers indentations over one inch that are not the result of an improper foundation or misuse. The mattress cover is protected in the first year of the warranty, but after that, it does not qualify for repair or replacement. If mattress repair is deemed necessary, the customer must pay for the shipping, and Nolah makes all shipping arrangements.
The Signature comes with a limited lifetime prorated warranty. In the first 15 years of the warranty, Nolah will replace or repair defective mattresses, including all shipping costs. If the mattress needs to be replaced between the 15th and 25th years, the owner will have to pay transportation costs plus 50 percent of the original purchase price. After year 25, a defective mattress will be replaced at 60 percent of the original purchase price plus the cost of shipping. The Signature’s warranty includes the same indentation policy and restrictions as the Original.
Nolah’s Social Responsibility
Nolah has a unique take on social responsibility. For each mattress sold, Nolah adopts an endangered animal. The customer gets to pick one of 20 endangered species for their purchase to sponsor.
Their foams are also CertiPUR-US® certified, so they’re guaranteed to be made without harmful substances like heavy metals and chemical flame retardants.
Who Are Nolah Mattresses For?
The Original and soft side of the Signature are best for devoted side sleepers due to the conformability of their thick AirFoam™ comfort layers. Nolah even advertises that their mattresses cater to side and back sleepers.
However, the firm side of the Signature offers firmer support for stomach sleepers and those who prefer a firm mattress. If you’re not sure what kind of comfort you prefer, the Signature gives you two options. Either model would work for couples due to their excellent motion isolation.
Amerisleep vs. Nolah: The Bottom Line
- Amerisleep offers more support and comfort options for all sleep positions and sleepers of different weights.
- Both companies have mattresses that cradle and conform to the curves of the body and use cooling technologies to prevent heat retention.
- Nolah mattresses cost slightly less than comparable Amerisleep models.
- Amerisleep has a better indentation policy included with their warranty.
A mattress is a personal decision that will affect you for the life of the mattress. While these two manufacturers have some similarities, their mattresses offer different benefits. Think about what you really need, including your sleep preferences and preferred sleep position. Take comfort in sleep trials. They give you a chance to make sure of your choice so that you get a comfortable night’s rest.
*The FDA has determined that Celliant® products are medical devices as defined in section 201(h) of the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act and are general wellness products. Celliant® is determined by the FDA to temporarily promote increased local blood flow at the site of application in healthy individuals. Hologenix, LLC, the maker of Celliant®, states that Celliant® safely converts body heat to infrared energy. This energy penetrates into the muscle and tissue to promote a temporary increase in local blood flow and helps increase comfort and promotes restful sleep.